We knew we wanted Mexican food on Friday night. We almost always have Mexican food on Friday nights. But what to do when you’re in a strange town for the first time and you don’t know where to go? Ask the locals.
We arrived in San Diego on Thursday afternoon. On the way to the hotel I asked the limo driver where the best Mexican food in town was. He gave us a name, then called his wife to confirm the location.
The driver was a nice guy, but a little strange so I decided to get a second opinion. Janet and I were sitting at the hotel pool bar drinking below-average Mai Tai’s, and I posed my question to the bartender. He gave the same answer as the limo driver, and pointed out that the place had homemade tortillas.
Friday afternoon as we were leaving the San Diego Zoo we stopped in to the gift shop and just for grins I asked the woman ringing up our souvenirs where the best Mexican food in town was. To my surprise her answer matched the other two. Casa Guadalajara got three votes out of three from the locals, so off we went.
We arrived at Casa Guadalajara between 4:30 and 4:45 and the place was already filling up but we got seated almost immediately. Someone in the dining room had a pina colada that looked pretty good so we both ordered one. It was one of the best pina coladas that I’ve ever had.
We sat munching our chips and salsa – not too mild but not too spicy either – and looked over the menu. There was a lot to choose from, but we decided to start off with the Ceviche a la Duran. The ceviche was loaded with large chunks of fish swimming with onions and avocado in a citrus tomato broth. The fish was really good and you make a meal out of the tomato soup.
For the main dish, Janet selected the Carnitas a la Michoacan. They really piled the pork on the plate, with both tender and crispy pieces available. It tasted like it had been simmered for hours and picked up all the subtle flavors. It rated up there with some of the best carnitas I’ve eaten.
I was really tempted to get one of the combo plates so I could sample lots of stuff, but I finally picked Pollo Mole Poblano. The mole sauce wasn’t what I expected, but I remembered that there are hundreds, perhaps thousands of different mole recipes. This mole sauce did have a chocolate base like others I’ve had, but it also had a distinctive peanut flavor. I was aware that some moles use peanut butter as a base, and this was one of them. Casa Guadalajara’s mole poblano is good; not the best I’ve ever had but I would certainly order it again.
We also ordered a cheese enchilada on the side and split that. It was really good, one of the better enchiladas I’ve tasted. The red sauce was flavorful but didn’t drown out the cheese enchilada. They did a really good job.
Normally the refried beans that come on the side at most Mexican restaurants are forgettable at beset. The beans at Casa Guadalajara were really good. I was a bit disappointed with the rice. It was loaded with vegetables and had an okay flavor, but it just didn’t work for me. Janet thought the rice was great, so your opinion may be different from mine.
When I placed my order, the waiter asked me if I wanted flour or corn tortillas. I responded that I wanted what ever was homemade. Those would be the flour tortillas, and they were incredible. Flour tortillas that were dough five minutes ago have an amazingly fresh flavor. Those alone are worth the trip.
If you go to Casa Guadalajara, go early. The place was full by 5:10, and when we left at 5:45 or so, the wait for an inside table was about 20 minutes or more. The patio tables were also packed, and both areas had lots of people waiting. The next time I’m in San Diego, I’m definitely going back.