We went to see the live version of Disney’s The Lion King last night. I should say up front that I don’t care much for the cartoon movie of the same thing. And not because The Lion King is a rip off of Shakespeare’s Hamlet except with singing and dancing animals. Everyone rips off Shakespeare, not just Disney. Something about that movie just doesn’t work for me and at most I tolerate it. Besides, I think South Park’s parody Cycle of Poo is a much better song than Circle of Life.
Anyway, we went downtown to see the live performance. Overall, it was pretty good but not great. And the problem wasn’t the story line, it was the singers. Very few of them could be considered top tier stars. There were exceptions, of course. Young Simba sounded like a young Michael Jackson and was very good. Both young and old Nala show a lot of potential as well. Mufasa had a decent voice, but when he appeared in the reflection I had to mutter, “Luke, I am your father.” So, there were bright spots.
But grown Simba? Whenever he would sing I kept thinking, “Is that all you’ve got? Why are you the star?” I was not impressed with him at all. Simba and most of the rest of the cast would have gotten through the first round of American Idol, but would never have made the finals. Their voices just lack the power and emotion I’ve seen in other musicals.
Scar was pretty good, but should have been more evil. And Simba’s mother could have been dropped from the show and no one would have noticed. Also, I find the characters Timon, Pumbaa, and Ed very grating. I don’t know why, I just do.
Of the few live musicals I’ve seen, The Lion King doesn’t compare well.
Technorati Tags: theater